Last updated at 1:04 pm ET on Nov. 12

Chautauqua County Legislature

On current results, 1 seat would change parties: District 9 (Democratic to Republican). Republicans would keep control, 13–6.

AlbanyAlleganyNew York CityBroomeCattaraugusCayugaChemungChenangoClintonColumbiaCortlandDelawareDutchessErieEssexFranklinFultonGeneseeGreeneHamiltonHerkimerJeffersonNew York CityLewisLivingstonMadisonMonroeMontgomeryNassauNew York CityNiagaraOneidaOnondagaOntarioOrangeOrleansOswegoOtsegoPutnamNew York CityRensselaerNew York CityRocklandSt. LawrenceSaratogaSchenectadySchoharieSchuylerSenecaSteubenSuffolkSullivanTiogaTompkinsUlsterWarrenWashingtonWayneWestchesterWyomingYatesChautauqua
Population
124,126
2024 president
Trump +21.8
Harris 38.7% · Trump 60.5%
Party in majority
Republicans (12–7)
County budget
$383 million
County Executive
Paul M. (PJ) Wendel Jr. R
Seats contested
68%
13 of 19 seats on the ballot
6 Democrats10 for a majority13 Republicans
DemocratRepublicanConservativeIndependentSeats on the ballot in the color of the most votes so far

2026 races

District 1

Held by Marcus S. Buchanan D

CandidateVotesShare
Marcus BuchananDemocratic, Working Families, Taxpayer's1,086 54.7%
Colby GarzaRepublican, Conservative900 45.3%

District 2

Held by Robert K. Bankoski D · unopposed

CandidateVotesShare
Robert BankoskiDemocratic, Working Families992 98.7%
Write-ins131.3%

District 3

Held by Robert M. "Bob" Scudder R

CandidateVotesShare
Bob ScudderRepublican, Conservative1,571 56.8%
Michael LeeDemocratic, Working Families1,195 43.2%
Write-ins10.0%

District 4

Held by Sandra A. Lewis D · unopposed

CandidateVotesShare
Sandra LewisDemocratic1,118 98.9%
Write-ins121.1%

District 5

Held by Jason C. Merritt R · unopposed

CandidateVotesShare
Jay MerrittRepublican, Conservative2,217 99.6%
Write-ins100.4%

District 6

Held by Thomas R. "Tom" Harmon R

CandidateVotesShare
Thomas HarmonRepublican, Conservative1,456 61.0%
Kevin O'ConnellDemocratic, Working Families931 39.0%

District 7

Held by Johnathan R. "John" Penhollow R

CandidateVotesShare
Johnathan PenhollowRepublican, Conservative1,567 65.5%
Carla RodriguezDemocratic, Working Families825 34.5%

District 8

Held by Pierre E. Chagnon R · unopposed

CandidateVotesShare
Pierre ChagnonRepublican, Conservative2,308 99.7%
Write-ins60.3%

District 9

Held by Vincent DeJoy III D

CandidateVotesShare
John VoganRepublican, Conservative795 50.3%
Vincent DeJoy IIIDemocratic783 49.5%
Write-ins40.3%

District 10

Held by Jamie S. Gustafson R

CandidateVotesShare
Jamie GustafsonRepublican, Conservative1,518 57.4%
Julie Jackson-ForsbergDemocratic, Working Families1,124 42.5%
Write-ins10.0%

District 11

Held by Robert W. "Bob" Whitney Jr. D

CandidateVotesShare
Robert W. Whitney Jr.Democratic, Taxpayer's808 50.4%
Jeremy MaggioRepublican, Conservative793 49.4%
Write-ins30.2%

District 12

Held by Frederick A. Larson D

CandidateVotesShare
Frederick A. LarsonDemocratic, Working Families964 52.6%
Brent P. SheldonRepublican, Conservative869 47.4%

District 13

Held by Thomas M. "Tom" Nelson D

CandidateVotesShare
Thomas NelsonDemocratic, Working Families636 53.5%
Andrew FaulknerRepublican, Conservative552 46.5%

District 14

Held by Daniel W. Pavlock R · unopposed

CandidateVotesShare
Daniel PavlockRepublican, Conservative2,286 99.5%
Write-ins120.5%

District 15

Held by Lisa A. Vanstrom R

CandidateVotesShare
Lisa VanstromRepublican, Conservative1,406 59.0%
Nikki PierceDemocratic, Taxpayer's977 41.0%

District 16

Held by Dalton J. Anthony R

CandidateVotesShare
Dalton AnthonyRepublican, Conservative2,064 77.4%
Christopher DeBlassDemocratic, Working Families601 22.5%
Write-ins10.0%

District 17

Held by Travis B. Heiser R · unopposed

CandidateVotesShare
Travis HeiserRepublican, Conservative1,893 99.6%
Write-ins70.4%

District 18

Held by Martin J. "Marty" Proctor R

CandidateVotesShare
Martin ProctorRepublican, Conservative1,583 64.5%
Dan MortonDemocratic873 35.5%

District 19

Held by Frederick S. Johnson R

CandidateVotesShare
Frederick JohnsonRepublican, Conservative1,530 59.8%
John HamelsDemocratic, Working Families1,028 40.2%
Write-ins10.0%