Republish this article

Legislature Seeks to End “Arbitrary Limit” on Medicaid Spending

Story and multimedia republishing rules

All our stories are published under Creative Commons, meaning that you are free to copy and distribute in your publication.
You may edit material to reflect relative changes in time, location and in-house style (for example, changing “yesterday” to “last week.”) If you’d like to make more substantive edits, like condensing stories, please run them by alex@nysfocus.com before publishing.
Bylines should credit New York Focus, in this format: “By [name of reporter], New York Focus”
Include the following language at the top of the story, with a link to our newsletter:

This story originally appeared in New York Focus, a nonprofit news publication investigating power in New York. Sign up for their newsletter here.

Please link back to our original story in the attribution line as well and include all hyperlinks from the original piece in the republished version.
If you share the story on social media, please mention @nysfocus (Twitter/X, Bluesky, Threads, Facebook, Instagram, TikTok).
Don’t sell the story or any part of it — it may not be marketed as a product.
Don’t extract, store or resell New York Focus content as a database.
Don’t sell ads against the story. But you can publish it with pre-sold ads.
Your website must include a prominent way to contact you.
You must obtain permission to package additional elements with our story and must label them.
You can republish our photos, illustrations, graphics and multimedia elements, but only with stories with which they originally appeared. You may not separate multimedia elements for standalone use. If you’re having trouble accessing visual elements, let us know.
If we send you a request to change or remove New York Focus content from your site, you must do so immediately.

For questions regarding the New York Focus publishing rules, or if you are a journalist or news organization that wants to join our partner list, please contact Alex Arriaga, Audience Engagement Editor, at alex@nysfocus.com.

This story originally appeared in <a href="https://nysfocus.com/2021/03/29/budget-medicaid-cap-repeal">New York Focus</a>, a nonprofit news publication investigating power in New York. <a href="https://nysfocus.com/newsletter?utm_source=partner&utm_medium=website" target="_blank">Sign up for their newsletter here</a>.<hr>NEW YORK STATE · March 29, 2021
<h1>Legislature Seeks to End “Arbitrary Limit” on Medicaid Spending</h1>
<h2>A 2011 rule prevents New York from adequately funding Medicaid, advocates say. This year’s budget could see it repealed.</h2>
<h3>By <a class="yellow-underline" href="https://nysfocus.com/author/sam-mellins">Sam Mellins</a> , New York Focus</h3><figure><img src="https://imgproxy.gridwork.co/rfyIp4W6r8IPPSze15EUs4jHkPBtJ37R8vHNF1_OJHc/w:820/h:657/rt:fill/g:fp:0.5:0.5/q:90/el:1/aHR0cHM6Ly9zMy51cy1lYXN0LTIuYW1hem9uYXdzLmNvbS9ueXNmb2N1cy9tZWRpY2FpZC1yYWxseS00LWUxNjE3MDI1NjE3MjI4LmpwZWc.jpeg" alt="" /><figcaption>Assemblymember Richard Gottfried speaks at a rally against Medicaid cuts / Medicaid Matters NY</figcaption></figure><div>In his first months in office in 2011, Governor Andrew Cuomo signed into law a package of sweeping cuts and reforms to the state’s Medicaid program, in an effort to rein in what he described as its “<a href="https://www.governor.ny.gov/news/governor-cuomo-accepts-recommendations-medicaid-redesign-team">out-of-control spending</a>.” A key measure in the package was the Medicaid Global Cap, which restricts yearly growth of New York’s Medicaid spending and has played a major role in structuring health policy in the state since it was enacted. 
But in their proposals for this year’s budget, for the first time, both houses of the legislature have proposed scrapping the cap, saying that it damages the quality of healthcare in New York State. 
“The purpose of the cap, plain and simple, is to cut down on Medicaid spending—not based on merit or sound health policy, just based on a political decision to spend less on healthcare for the poor and frail, the elderly and people with disabilities,” Assembly Health Committee Chair Richard Gottfried told New York Focus. “We need to get rid of it for the current budget.” 
The legislature’s proposal to reject the cap has alarmed conservative health policy experts. 
“Repealing the cap sends a really unfortunate signal,” said Bill Hammond, a health policy fellow at the Empire Center for Public Policy, a fiscally conservative think tank. “It sends the signal that we’re cutting the break line, and we’re going to floor it from now on—cost is no object when it comes to Medicaid.” 
New York’s Medicaid program, which provides public health insurance to over 7 million low-income New Yorkers, is more expensive per capita than the programs in <a href="https://www.kff.org/medicaid/state-indicator/medicaid-spending-per-enrollee/?currentTimeframe=0&sortModel=%7B%22colId%22:%22All%20Full%20or%20Partial%20Benefit%20Enrollees%22,%22sort%22:%22desc%22%7D">most other states</a>, in large part because it is <a href="https://www.cbpp.org/research/health/medicaid-and-medicare-enrollees-need-dental-vision-and-hearing-benefits">more generous</a>. Unlike many other states, New York covers prescription drugs, vision, and dental care. 
“Our higher Medicaid spending level is not because we're throwing money away, it’s because we are doing a better job than other states in paying for healthcare,” Gottfried said. 
The cap, tied to the Consumer Price Index, restricts the yearly growth of the state’s Medicaid spending to a low-single-digit percentage. The governor often invokes the cap in negotiations with the legislature to justify implementing cuts and rejecting service expansions, advocates said. 
But despite frequent mentions of the cap, advocates said that enforcement is selective, as the budgetary process allows certain costs to be “exempted” from the cap. Budget observers said that this gives the governor, who plays the dominant role in the budget process, a powerful tool to control state funds—he can and does cite the cap when arguing for cuts or rejecting the legislature’s spending proposals, but <a href="http://crainsnewyork.com/article/20160419/HEALTH_CARE/160419864/gov-andrew-cuomo-agrees-to-pay-health-care-employers-millions-to-raise-minimum-wage">exempt from it expenses he supports</a>. 
For the next fiscal year, Hammond noted, the cap authorizes about $20 billion in state Medicaid spending—but the budget proposed by Governor Cuomo contains $28 billion. 
“When the governor has wanted to, he has had no qualms about excluding some items from the cap, and then a year later putting them back under the cap without any explanation,” Gottfried said. 
Even selectively enforced, the cap has negatively impacted the quality of the state’s Medicaid program, advocates said. 
“The Medicaid budget has been subject to ten years of austerity and cuts. People in need of home care simply cannot find aides; we have crumbling public hospitals that bear the brunt of Medicaid cuts because they rely so heavily on state funding. It’s very easy to see how our entire delivery system has suffered because of the cap,” said Lara Kassel, coordinator of Medicaid Matters New York, a group that advocates for Medicaid recipients. 
Last year’s budget included <a href="https://www.cityandstateny.com/articles/policy/budget/medicaid-cuts-make-state-budget-some-tweaks.html">significant cuts to Medicaid</a>, including $138 million of cuts to New York City’s public hospital system. “The cap gives him cover,” Amanda Dunker, a senior health policy associate at the Community Service Society of New York, told New York Focus. “It gives him a way to propose these types of cuts.” 
“The cap allows the governor to point to an arbitrary limit that shuts down any negotiation over investment,” Kassel said. “When we exceed the cap he calls it a deficit, and says we need to make cuts in the program. We don’t see that as a deficit, we see that as spending that needs to happen.” 
Lifting the cap would enable greater investment in the state’s public health care system, such as increased support of public hospitals and community health centers and higher wages for <a href="https://phinational.org/wp-content/uploads/legacy/clearinghouse/PHI-495%20NY%20ExecSummary.pdf">low-paid home health aides</a>, advocates said. 
Gottfried said that as a blanket restriction on growth, the cap ignores a number of natural causes of Medicaid cost increases. “It has never fully accommodated real inflation in healthcare costs. It doesn’t account for the aging of the Medicaid population, and it ignores the growth in the number of people who are income eligible for Medicaid,” he said. 
Because it does not account for enrollment, the cap effectively requires per-enrollee cuts in years when significantly more people enroll for Medicaid. 
Between March and November 2020, over 700,000 New Yorkers enrolled in Medicaid as many lost employment-based insurance due to the economic downturn caused by COVID-19. While this placed significant additional costs on the system, Kassel said that the program’s ability to respond to such shocks is a virtue. “Medicaid is a safety net program that did what it was supposed to do in 2020,” she said. 
Medicaid advocates say that there are ways to shrink Medicaid spending without cutting services. Naomi Zewde, a professor of public health at the City University of New York, said that New York could cut spending without reducing services by eliminating contracts with expensive managed care programs, cutting out the middleman in provision of care, as <a href="https://portal.ct.gov/-/media/Departments-and-Agencies/DSS/Communications/HUSKY-Health---Five-Key-Points.pdf">Connecticut did in 2012</a>. 97% of Connecticut’s Medicaid budget goes <a href="https://portal.ct.gov/-/media/Departments-and-Agencies/DSS/Communications/HUSKY-Health---Five-Key-Points.pdf">directly to providing healthcare</a>, in contrast to <a href="https://www.rand.org/pubs/research_reports/RR2424.html">93% in New York</a>, Zewde noted. 
Whether the legislature’s proposal to end the cap makes it into the final budget could depend on to what degree legislative leadership prioritizes the issue in negotiations with the governor. 
“The Assembly and the Senate are in negotiations to have a united front when it comes to negotiating with the governor,” Kassel said. “Our hope is that repeal of the cap will be something that will make it to the top of their priority list.”</div>	 
<script src="https://nysfocus.com/pixel.js" id="republish" data-origin-url="https://nysfocus.com/2021/03/29/budget-medicaid-cap-repeal"></script>