Republish this article

Hector LaSalle’s Chief Judge Shot Ends With Historic Rejection by State Senate

Story and multimedia republishing rules

All our stories are published under Creative Commons, meaning that you are free to copy and distribute in your publication.
You may edit material to reflect relative changes in time, location and in-house style (for example, changing “yesterday” to “last week.”) If you’d like to make more substantive edits, like condensing stories, please run them by alex@nysfocus.com before publishing.
Bylines should credit New York Focus, in this format: “By [name of reporter], New York Focus”
Include the following language at the top of the story, with a link to our newsletter:

This story originally appeared in New York Focus, a nonprofit news publication investigating power in New York. Sign up for their newsletter here.

Please link back to our original story in the attribution line as well and include all hyperlinks from the original piece in the republished version.
If you share the story on social media, please mention @nysfocus (Twitter/X, Bluesky, Threads, Facebook, Instagram, TikTok).
Don’t sell the story or any part of it — it may not be marketed as a product.
Don’t extract, store or resell New York Focus content as a database.
Don’t sell ads against the story. But you can publish it with pre-sold ads.
Your website must include a prominent way to contact you.
You must obtain permission to package additional elements with our story and must label them.
You can republish our photos, illustrations, graphics and multimedia elements, but only with stories with which they originally appeared. You may not separate multimedia elements for standalone use. If you’re having trouble accessing visual elements, let us know.
If we send you a request to change or remove New York Focus content from your site, you must do so immediately.

For questions regarding the New York Focus publishing rules, or if you are a journalist or news organization that wants to join our partner list, please contact Alex Arriaga, Audience Engagement Editor, at alex@nysfocus.com.

This story originally appeared in <a href="https://nysfocus.com/2023/02/15/hector-lasalle-rejected-state-senate-hochul">New York Focus</a>, a nonprofit news publication investigating power in New York. <a href="https://nysfocus.com/newsletter?utm_source=partner&utm_medium=website" target="_blank">Sign up for their newsletter here</a>.<hr>CRIMINAL JUSTICE · February 15, 2023
<h1>Hector LaSalle’s Chief Judge Shot Ends With Historic Rejection by State Senate</h1>
<h2>The surprise vote was a stinging rebuke to Governor Kathy Hochul, who pushed aggressively for LaSalle’s confirmation.</h2>
<h3>By <a class="yellow-underline" href="https://nysfocus.com/author/sam-mellins">Sam Mellins</a> , New York Focus</h3><figure><img src="https://imgproxy.gridwork.co/p1kL5kcBac_g6L64AQK624MY2omL3vqdIprD3ZH-OqA/w:820/h:615/rt:fill/g:fp:0.5:0.5/q:90/el:1/aHR0cHM6Ly9zMy51cy1lYXN0LTIuYW1hem9uYXdzLmNvbS9ueXNmb2N1cy9JTUdfMjQ3Ni1zY2FsZWRfMjAyMy0wMy0wOC0yMDQ4NDZfanlsZy5qcGc.jpg" alt="" /><figcaption>Hector LaSalle testified before the Senate Judiciary Committee last month. / Sam Mellins / New York Focus</figcaption></figure><div>IN A SURPRISE floor vote on Wednesday, the state Senate brought Judge Hector LaSalle’s candidacy for New York’s chief judge to an end. The move concluded a months-long battle between Governor Kathy Hochul and opponents who <a href="https://nysfocus.com/2022/12/19/chief-judge-court-of-appeals-hector-lasalle/">saw her pick as too conservative</a> to head New York’s highest court. It also mooted a lawsuit from Senate Republicans seeking to force the vote. 
In a massive rebuke to Hochul, 39 out of the chamber’s 63 senators voted to reject LaSalle — with Democrats casting all but one of the votes against him. It was the first time that the Senate has rejected a governor’s nominee to the Court of Appeals, as New York’s highest state court is known. 
“We are taking this matter to the floor today to resolve this crisis,” said Senate Deputy Majority Leader Michael Gianaris, speaking on the Senate floor shortly before the vote. “The Senate is standing up to do the right thing for the people” 
Last month, the Senate Judiciary Committee <a href="https://nysfocus.com/2023/01/18/hector-lasalle-rejected-senate-committee/">rejected LaSalle 10–9</a>, with just three of the committee’s 13 Democrats — and all six of its Republicans — voting to advance his nomination to the full Senate. 
Senate Democrats said the committee vote was enough to kill his nomination, but last week, Republican Senator Anthony Palumbo <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2023/02/09/nyregion/judge-lasalle-lawsuit.html">sued Senate Majority Leader</a> Andrea Stewart-Cousins and other Democratic senators, claiming that the state constitution requires the full Senate to vote on the nomination. Holding the vote eliminated the reason for the suit: There’s now no dispute that LaSalle’s nomination has been rejected. 
"This vote is an important victory for the Constitution. But it was not a vote on the merits of Justice LaSalle, who is an overwhelmingly qualified and talented jurist," Hochul said in a statement released after the vote. She had also argued that the constitution required the full Senate to vote. 
“Today, the Senate Majority will once again rise to our leadership responsibilities and end the ongoing distraction of the Justice Hector LaSalle nomination,” Stewart-Cousins said in a statement released before the vote. “Our highest court has no appointed Chief Judge, and we need the court system to function. This court case, if allowed to continue, would’ve dragged on for months and stymied our judicial system. It’s time to put this matter to rest.” 
Palumbo, who is the highest-ranking Republican on the judiciary committee, said on the Senate floor that Senate Democrats were trying to “pack the court with activists who choose not to follow the law, unlike Judge Hector LaSalle.” 
Speaking to reporters in New York City before the vote, Hochul sought to frame it as a win for proper procedure. 
“I think this is a good outcome, to at least let it go to the floor of the Senate,” she said. “I believe that the constitution requires this to go to the full Senate for a vote. That was disputed up until today.” 
LaSalle would have been the first Latino chief judge of the Court of Appeals. Several Latino political power brokers in New York — including Representative Adriano Espaillat, state Senator Luis Sepúlveda, and influential lobbyist Luis Miranda — aggressively supported his nomination. 
But they were outflanked by a <a href="https://nysfocus.com/2022/12/22/chief-judge-court-of-appeals-hochul-picks-hector-lasalle/">broad coalition that rallied against LaSalle</a>, including dozens of law professors, major labor unions, reproductive rights groups, criminal justice reform advocates, and many liberal and progressive state senators. They argued that LaSalle’s record as a judge was unfriendly towards unions, reproductive rights, and people accused of crimes. 
The seven-member Court of Appeals currently has <a href="https://nysfocus.com/2022/07/12/difiore-resignation-court-of-appeals/">three judges who lean conservative</a> and three who lean more liberal, meaning that the next chief judge could <a href="https://nysfocus.com/2022/11/28/kathy-hochul-new-york-court-of-appeals-shortlist/">determine which bloc controls the court</a> going forward. All three of the more liberal judges applied for the chief judge spot, but were not shortlisted by the panel that screens applicants for the Court of Appeals, New York Focus <a href="https://nysfocus.com/2022/12/01/court-of-appeals-chief-judge-difiore-dissenters/">previously reported</a>. 
New York’s previous chief judge, Janet DiFiore, led the Court of Appeals toward <a href="https://nysfocus.com/2022/07/07/court-of-appeals-conservative-bloc/">more conservative rulings</a> that hemmed in the rights of criminal defendants, workers, and consumers. Before Hochul nominated LaSalle, numerous state senators said they wanted a new chief judge who would reverse that trend and serve as a counterweight to a conservative US Supreme Court. 
Hochul selected LaSalle in December from a list of seven candidates prepared by the screening panel. He was generally considered to be one of the more moderate candidates, and a coalition of community groups <a href="https://www.cityandstateny.com/politics/2022/12/3-nominees-progressives-wont-tolerate-new-yorks-highest-court/380631/">warned Hochul</a> that if she chose him, they would rally against his confirmation. 
With his nomination rejected, the panel must now prepare a new list of seven candidates, from which Hochul will again select one for the Senate’s consideration. 
Leaving an event in Manhattan shortly before the vote, Hochul said: “The process starts again.”</div>	 
<script src="https://nysfocus.com/pixel.js" id="republish" data-origin-url="https://nysfocus.com/2023/02/15/hector-lasalle-rejected-state-senate-hochul"></script>