Oh, There It Is! Bronx Dems Fix Disclosure Failure After New York Focus Reporting.

The disclosures included over a dozen missing or incomplete reports covering a period of more than four years.

Sam Mellins and Chris Bragg   ·   October 22, 2024
The word "fixed" is overlaid on top of a Bronx city skyline with a background of $20 bills.
The Bronx Democratic Party reported hundreds of thousands of dollars in previously undisclosed donations on Friday, Oct. 18, 2024. | Images Money and Mike Cohen via Flickr + Brad Racino

The Bronx Democratic Party reported hundreds of thousands of dollars in previously undisclosed donations on Friday following reporting from New York Focus that found the group had failed to disclose dozens of political contributions — a violation of state law.

A political action committee dedicated to electing Democrats to the state Assembly donated nearly $700,000 to the Bronx party, according to the new disclosures. The honorary chair of the committee is Assembly Speaker Carl Heastie, who represents part of the Bronx and is one of the most powerful figures in state politics.

State senator and Bronx Democratic Party head Jamaal Bailey told New York Focus that the omission was due to “inaccurate record keeping.” He said that the party would improve its practices going forward.

“There’s no impropriety. There’s nothing wrong. We simply didn’t file when we were supposed to,” Bailey said.

The disclosure failure first came to New York Focus’s notice because the PAC — the New York State Democratic Assembly Campaign Committee — had reported sending more than $400,000 to the Bronx in 24 installments, but the Bronx party had never reported receiving the cash.

The new disclosures revealed the PAC was not the only undisclosed source of funds. The Bronx party also received five-figure contributions from sources like the New York Yankees and the industry lobbying group PhRMA, as noted by Politico.

Since April of 2020, the Democratic Assembly PAC has sent over $690,000 to the Bronx party. But for the 20 years prior (as far back as the public data goes), there are no records of the PAC donating to the Bronx.

Bailey said that money has been used for “party building” in the Bronx. Assemblymember Jeffrey Dinowitz, who chairs the Assembly PAC and also represents the Bronx, has echoed that justification.

Neither Bailey nor Dinowitz offered a reason for why the transfers began in 2020.

Why hundreds of thousands of dollars are required for Democratic party building in a county where Democrats outnumber Republicans by more than ten to one is unclear. The Assembly PAC, chaired by Dinowitz and Heastie, did not give substantial amounts of money to any other county-based Democratic party in the last five years.

It also didn’t financially support Democratic Assemblymember Steven Englebright, who was defeated by a Republican in the 2022 election cycle, despite Englebright requesting help, he previously told New York Focus.

Bailey denied that the Bronx donations deprived other candidates.

“The Bronx got resources, and other places got resources as well,” Bailey said.

Dinowitz did not respond to a request for comment on why the Assembly PAC sent over half a million dollars to the Bronx. He told New York Focus last week that despite being the chair of the PAC, he wasn’t aware that they’d sent money to the Bronx.

“I’m not the person who signs checks. I’m not the treasurer, or anything like that,” he said at the time.

The Democratic Assembly PAC and its executive director, David Waterman, have not responded to multiple contact attempts.

Since New York Focus reported on the undisclosed funds, Bronx Democrats have submitted over a dozen new or amended filings to the state Board of Elections covering 2020 through 2024. The party filed multiple reports that had previously been entirely absent from public records, and disclosed expenses that had been missing from previous reports.

The state chief of election law enforcement, Michael Johnson, did not respond to questions from New York Focus asking whether he plans to investigate the years-late disclosures.

Sam Mellins is senior reporter at New York Focus, which he has been a part of since launch day. His reporting has also appeared in The San Francisco Chronicle, The Intercept, THE CITY, and The Nation. 
Chris Bragg is the Albany bureau chief at New York Focus. He has done investigative reporting on New York government and politics since 2009, most recently at The Buffalo News and Albany Times Union.
Also filed in Elections

Pomerantz LLP attorneys have donated to comptroller candidates for decades, highlighting a loophole in rules meant to keep government contractors from spending in city elections.

The chair of Assembly Democrats’ campaign committee said he wasn’t aware his organization had sent hundreds of thousands of dollars to the Bronx.

The indictment has exposed cracks in New York’s widely admired way of helping fund campaigns.

Also filed in New York State

Years of shortages have led to a staggering problem across the state, with few solutions on the horizon.

New rules from the Biden administration require water utilities to replace all lead pipes. That could cost New York $2.5 billion or more, kicking off a fight over who pays.

A week after incarcerated journalist Sara Kielly published an article criticizing the prison system for its solitary confinement practices, officers ransacked her cell.

Also filed in New York City

Foreign governments have long courted local officials. Prosecutors are starting to go after them.

The mayor and governor have long hailed their partnership. Will it survive federal corruption charges?

From New York City to Buffalo, people are driving a lot more than they did before the pandemic.