Josh Shapiro Is Using Highway Money to Save Mass Transit. Could Hochul Follow?

New York has a little-noticed tool to shift billions of highway dollars to climate-friendly public transit projects. The governor doesn’t seem interested.

Sam Mellins   ·   December 9, 2024
Governors Kathy Hochul and Josh Shapiro spliced together
Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro diverted highway funding to public transit. Hochul has so far declined to take that move. | Images: Offices of Governors Kathy Hochul, Josh Shapiro | Illustration: New York Focus

Until last month, Philadelphia’s mass transit system was facing a “death spiral.” With fare revenue still below pre-pandemic levels and federal aid drying up, transit officials were warning of unprecedented fare hikes and service cuts — both things that discourage transit use and would have likely accelerated the decline.

Then Governor Josh Shapiro stepped in and single-handedly saved the system. He did it by using an easily available but little-used tool to boost transit funding at no cost to taxpayers or transit riders.

The federal government sends states billions of dollars each year to improve and maintain their transportation systems. By default, 80 percent of that money is allocated to highways and 20 percent to mass transit. But that’s not set in stone: Governors can choose to shift up to half of their state’s highway funding to transit instead, a move known as “flexing” the funds. Transit advocates and climate groups have urged governors to make wider use of this power to boost mass transit and reduce the environmentally harmful effects of highway expansion and car use.

Shapiro did just that. $153 million in funds that were allocated to highways will now go to the Southeastern Pennsylvania Transportation Authority instead, placing the agency on firm footing until state politicians can work out a permanent funding solution next year.

Meanwhile in New York, Governor Kathy Hochul’s decision to lower New York City’s maximum congestion pricing toll from $15 to $9 means that the state Metropolitan Transit Authority will likely slow down key upgrades and possibly pay more in interest on its loans, according to the state comptroller and independent experts.

Bolstering the congestion pricing revenue with highway funds could help keep the projects on track and prevent the growth of the MTA’s already heavy debt burden.

“It should absolutely be on the table,” said Alex Armlovich, who studies transit and housing at the politically moderate Niskanen Center and had called for Shapiro to shift highway funds to SEPTA. “Highway funding is a continuous fountain.”

New York Focus asked Governor Kathy Hochul, who calls herself a “champion” on climate issues, whether she will follow Shapiro’s example and use federal highway funds to close the gap left by lowering the congestion toll.

She said there’s no need.

“If you can do this in a purple state, then you can do it in a blue state.”

—Saul Levin, Green New Deal Network

“We’re not experiencing a gap. The same amount of money is going to be spent to make the major improvements,” she said. “I’m investing, like no other governor in history, in our mass transit systems.”

Even if the MTA eventually spends the same amount of money, some planned upgrades will likely take longer and cost more, according to Ana Champeny, vice president of the fiscally conservative think tank Citizens Budget Commission, since “the longer you wait to do a project, the more it costs.”

Hochul has said the lower $9 toll will still reduce traffic and air pollution, a key goal of the congestion pricing program, but the traffic relief her office anticipates is much smaller than what was predicted for the original plan.

Shifting highway funds to transit requires federal approval, and it’s not clear how the incoming Trump administration will respond to such requests.

Thanks to President Joe Biden’s Bipartisan Infrastructure Law, states have received a historic windfall of cash to spend on transportation. New York alone was allocated $36 billion, of which $15 billion can be spent on either roads or public transit.

So far, the overwhelming majority of that cash has gone to roads, New York Focus reported in February.

The state’s official climate plan recommends using federal funds to expand mass transit infrastructure. But Hochul’s Department of Transportation is using big chunks of the infrastructure law money to support an aggressive program of highway expansions, such as an estimated $1.3 billion project in the Catskill region that the state’s own study projects will save drivers a maximum of six minutes.

Projects like that across the country might end up making Biden’s infrastructure law a cause of increased greenhouse emissions — the exact opposite of what it was intended to accomplish.

“Because Democratic leaders have not been doing more on transit, Biden’s legacy on climate is being cut into,” said Saul Levin, political director of the Green New Deal Network.

That could change if Hochul and other governors follow the example of Shapiro, who is considered a leading contender for the 2028 Democratic presidential nomination.

Shapiro’s action followed a campaign from Pennsylvania transit advocacy groups to inform the public about flexible funds and pressure decision-makers.

“We sent, like, 3,500 letters to the governor in three weeks,” said Laura Chu Weins, executive director of Pittsburghers for Public Transit. “We had phone banking days where people were calling riders across the state to educate them on this possibility and the situation that was happening in Philly.”

There hasn’t been any comparable effort in New York, where flexible funds have largely flown under the radar. But the state could still shift gears.

“If you can do this in a purple state, then you can do it in a blue state,” Levin said.

Colin Kinniburgh contributed reporting.

At New York Focus, our central mission is to help readers better understand how New York really works. If you think this article succeeded, please consider supporting our mission and making more stories like this one possible.

New York is an incongruous state. We’re home to fabulous wealth — if the state were a country, it would have the tenth largest economy in the world — but also the highest rate of wealth inequality. We’re among the most diverse – but also the most segregated. We passed the nation’s most ambitious climate law — but haven’t been meeting its deadlines and continue to subsidize industries hastening the climate crisis.

As New York’s only statewide nonprofit news publication, our journalism exists to help you make sense of these contradictions. Our work scrutinizes how power works in the state, unpacks who’s really calling the shots, and reveals how obscure decisions shape ordinary New Yorkers’ lives.

In the last two decades, the number of local news outlets in New York have been nearly slashed in half, allowing elected officials and powerful individuals to increasingly operate in the dark — with the average New Yorker none the wiser.

We’re on a mission to change that. Our work has already shown what can happen when those with power know that someone is watching, with stories that have prompted policy changes and spurred legislation. We have ambitious plans for the rest of the year and beyond, including tackling new beats and more hard-hitting stories — but we need your help to make them a reality.

If you’re able, please consider supporting our journalism with a one-time gift or a monthly gift. We can't do this work without you.

Thank you,

Akash Mehta
Editor-in-Chief
Sam Mellins is senior reporter at New York Focus, which he has been a part of since launch day. His reporting has also appeared in The San Francisco Chronicle, The Intercept, THE CITY, and The Nation. 
Also filed in New York State

Much of Albany’s lawmaking process is controlled by a platoon of mostly young, low-paid employees who craft policy ideas into potential laws. And they’re turning over in droves.

New York Focus traveled across the state to meet with communities about their local news needs.

New York’s home care workers are suing insurance companies for systematically underpaying them for grueling, around-the-clock work.

Also filed in Budget

Here’s a simple explanation of a complicated and archaic formula — and why the state is updating it.

New financial disclosures show when Mujica began consulting for the Greater New York Hospital Association.

Hundreds of Child Victims Act cases have been filed against New York schools, some over accused serial offenders that could leave districts with tens of millions of dollars in liability.

Also filed in Transit

From New York City to Buffalo, people are driving a lot more than they did before the pandemic.

There are at least three ways a Trump administration could try to stop the transit-funding toll.

Hochul says she’s working with the legislature to replace congestion pricing, but key legislators say they aren’t aware of any conversations.