Hochul Punts on How to Reduce Traffic and Pollution in NYC

Hochul says she’s working with the legislature to replace congestion pricing, but key legislators say they aren’t aware of any conversations.

Sam Mellins   ·   August 9, 2024
Hochul at a podium
Governor Hochul has promised that the MTA’s funding issues will be “resolved in a few months.” | Susan Watts/Office of Governor Kathy Hochul

At a press conference Thursday, Governor Kathy Hochul refused to commit to achieving the reductions in air pollution and traffic that congestion pricing, which she indefinitely paused in June, was slated to produce.

Since her abrupt decision to put the years-in-the-making plan on hold punched a $15 billion hole in the budget of the Metropolitan Transportation Authority, Hochul has maintained that she will devise a replacement plan to fully fund the MTA and all of its planned upgrades and improvements.

The governor has declined to provide any details about how this will happen. And while she has suggested that she is working with the legislature to find a solution, key legislators said they aren’t aware of any active conversations between the governor and legislature on the issue.

In addition to providing funding for the MTA, congestion pricing was supposed to improve air quality and reduce record-high gridlock in downtown Manhattan and its surroundings, which are among the most congested urban areas in the world.

The tolling program would have reduced greenhouse gas emissions in downtown Manhattan by 11 percent and traffic by 17 percent, according to an MTA study.

Asked by New York Focus if she is still dedicated to meeting those metrics, Hochul merely stated that she is “committed to ensuring that there are benefits for the people who live in those areas.”

She then pivoted to the cost of congestion pricing for car owners in the Central Business District, the area of Manhattan below 60th street where the toll would have applied.

“Actually, people live in those areas who would have to pay an additional $15 to travel in and out of their own homes. That is an extraordinary cost,” she said.

Eighty percent of Central Business District residents live in households that do not own cars, according to the U.S. census.

State Senator Liz Krueger, who represents part of the Central Business District, said that Hochul declining to commit to congestion pricing’s planned environmental and traffic benefits is a “major concern.”

“Until now, she’s kept saying that we’re going to come up with an alternative that addresses those issues,” said Krueger, who has been a vocal critic of the pause.

Assemblymember Tony Simone, who also represents part of the Central Business District, sharply criticized Hochul’s statement.

“The governor has created a situation in which traffic and air quality conditions continue to worsen, and offers no solution to these crises,” he said. “Meanwhile, she is digging under the couch cushions for pennies for the MTA.”

Traffic accidents have killed far more people than gun violence in New York City so far this year, Gothamist reported in June.

Governor Hochul at a podium
Governor Hochul at a press conference on Thursday | Sam Mellins

New York Focus also asked Hochul why the $15 toll would be a greater economic hardship than the $30.50 cost of a round-trip train ticket from Tarrytown, a Westchester suburb, to Grand Central Terminal in Midtown.

Hochul suggested it was a cherry-picked example.

“I’m talking about people coming in from all over, not just that one train example that you’re using. People are coming in from other places, and it is expensive to ask them to pay this,” she said.

Almost all train fares from New York City’s suburbs cost more than $15. Peak-hour train tickets to Manhattan from Long Island’s suburbs cost a minimum of $26 round trip. It costs $16.60 to make a round trip from Montclair, New Jersey, to Penn Station during peak hours.

“To Governor Hochul’s surprise, many New Yorkers spend more than $15 every day to commute by train,” said Danny Pearlstein, policy director of the mass transit advocacy group Riders’ Alliance. “It’s absurd to block billions of dollars for public transit because of affordability without knowing the commuting costs that New Yorkers actually pay.”

On Tuesday, Hochul promised that the MTA’s funding issues would be “resolved in a few months” and said that “everybody will have clarity on what the path is going forward with the legislature.”

Several legislators said they’re unaware of any progress toward a replacement program.

“I read that she was talking to some people in the legislature about some new plan. So I called up my leader, who said, ‘She hasn’t talked to me about it,’” Krueger said, referring to Senate Democratic Majority Leader Andrea Stewart-Cousins.

Senator Brad Hoylman-Sigal and Assemblymember Harvey Epstein, who represent parts of the Central Business District, also said they aren’t aware of any active discussions between the governor and legislators about replacements for congestion pricing.

Most New Yorkers have an unfavorable view of congestion pricing. But Krueger said that the specter of dozens of canceled upgrades to subway, bus, and train infrastructure has turned some former opponents of the program into supporters.

“Even people in my district who had been publicly opposing congestion pricing forever,” she said, “now they’re calling and saying, ‘Okay, we thought we really didn’t want congestion pricing. This is so much worse. Tell her to go forward.’”

I hope this article helped you better answer the question that guides all of our journalism: Who runs New York? Before you click away, please consider supporting our work and making more stories like this one possible.

New York state is standing at a crossroads for climate action. After passing one of the nation’s most ambitious climate laws in 2019, the state is lagging far behind on its targets, struggling to meet deadlines to build renewable energy and clean up its buildings and roads. Other states are closely watching our progress, making decisions about their own climate plans based on New York’s ability to implement this legislation.

As New York’s only statewide nonprofit news publication, we’ve been scrutinizing the state’s climate progress. Our journalism exists to unpack how power works in New York, analyze who’s really calling the shots, and reveal how obscure decisions shape ordinary New Yorkers’ lives.

But we can't do this work without your help. We rely on reader donations to help sustain our outlet, and every gift directly allows us to publish more pieces like this.

Our work has already shown what can happen when those with power know that someone is watching, with my reporting prompting a state investigation and fine for a major corporation. I have more story ideas than I can count, but only limited resources to pursue all the leads that come across my desk.

If you’re able, please consider supporting our journalism with a one-time or monthly gift. Even small donations make a big difference.

Thank you for reading.

Colin Kinniburgh
Climate and Environmental Politics Reporter
Sam Mellins is senior reporter at New York Focus, which he has been a part of since launch day. His reporting has also appeared in The San Francisco Chronicle, The Intercept, THE CITY, and The Nation. 
Also filed in New York State

Our team will be descending upon Albany on Tuesday. Here’s what they’ll be watching.

New York’s plan to put a price on carbon could arrive in 2025. Here’s how it would work.

Updates about an increase in emissions, violence within New York’s prison system, and a breakup of two nonprofits over cannabis in NYC.

Also filed in New York City

Here are the major findings from a months-long investigation into what allegedly takes place inside the Queens Supreme Courthouse.

Brandon Bishunauth is an unlikely candidate to pick a fight with a bastion of old-time machine politics.

New York Focus education reporter Bianca Fortis reflects on the most important education stories in New York this year, and what to keep an eye on next year.

Also filed in Climate and Environment

One hundred and twenty-four laws that almost were.

New York Focus reporter Julia Rock reflects on her varied coverage of state policy in an end-of-year wrapup.

New York Focus climate reporter Colin Kinniburgh reflects on his environmental coverage over the past year and what’s coming on the beat in 2025.

Also filed in Transit

New York Focus reporter Sam Mellins reflects on what he learned this year, and teases what lies ahead for 2025.

New York has a little-noticed tool to shift billions of highway dollars to climate-friendly public transit projects. The governor doesn’t seem interested.

As the state’s plans to get New Yorkers out of their cars stall, Governor Hochul is championing a highway expansion in the Hudson Valley.