Summers Are Brutal in New York’s Prisons. This Year Is Worse Than Ever.

This year has been especially brutal. Whereas incarcerated people can normally spend much of their day working, taking classes, or participating in activities in cooler parts of facilities, most have spent the last five months largely confined to their cells or dorms, sometimes only getting a precious hour or two outside them.

“You have no sense of relief,” Desmond said. “You’re just sitting in a cell, baking.”

That’s because the state prison agency has severely limited out-of-cell time since corrections officers launched a three-week wildcat strike in February. The strike ended with some 2,000 officers losing their jobs; four months later, dozens of facilities are operating with anywhere from 30 to 60 percent fewer guards than the state prison agency says they need to operate. (Governor Kathy Hochul deployed the National Guard to staff the facilities during the strike, and about 3,000 servicemembers remain assigned to prisons, but prison administration doesn’t allow them to do most security work without trained corrections officers present.)

The prison agency has said it needs more guards than it currently has to supervise programs and escort incarcerated people from one area to another. To make up for the lack of officers, facilities have canceled or shortened college courses, religious services, work release, outdoor recreation, and more — and kept prisoners locked away.

“There’s no break,” said Jennifer Scaife, executive director of the Correctional Association of New York, a nonprofit tasked by the state with overseeing prison conditions.

Scaife recently visited Marcy Correctional Facility in Central New York on a 90-plus-degree day. “You could stand in front of someone’s cell and just feel hot, humid air pouring out,” she said.

Incarcerated people have long complained that heat raises tensions and can lead to violence. It can also exacerbate medical issues and is especially dangerous for elderly people, advocates have warned. Scaife was particularly concerned for those in Marcy’s mental health unit, since many psychiatric medications can make it harder for the body to regulate temperature.

“There’s 90 people in this unit,” she said. ”They’ve been essentially in those circumstances for months.”

During her visit, Scaife witnessed incarcerated men trying to marginally improve the temperature in their cells, by reminding guards to give them ice, per prison agency guidance, and convincing staff to install more fans in locations that facilitate airflow. New York prisons don’t allow incarcerated people to have large fans of their own. Facilities do allow each prisoner to have one small personal fan — but they have to buy those and obtain a permit to do so.

The nonprofit New Hour, which provides services to incarcerated and recently released women, raised over $9,000 to purchase fans for women in prison. The fans were about $20 a piece, said New Hour’s executive director, Serena Martin, and the organization had to buy them from one of the prison agency’s approved third-party vendors.

“Why isn’t this part of the budget?” said Martin. “It should be a mandatory thing that you get, like a pillow and a blanket.”

The Department of Corrections and Community Supervision, which runs the state prison system, did not answer questions about why it doesn’t provide free personal fans. It also didn’t answer questions about why it limits the size of fans incarcerated people can possess; Martin, who is formerly incarcerated herself, chalked that up to security policies aimed at limiting access to materials that can be fashioned into weapons.

Some have had trouble obtaining fans. Mary Maguire said the commissary at Elmira Correctional Facility, where her son is incarcerated, didn’t have them in stock for several weeks.

State Senator Julia Salazar, head of the chamber’s corrections committee, said in a statement that her office receives regular calls about difficulty accessing fans, among other complaints about the heat. The roughly $20 price tag “is more than most incarcerated people can afford,” she said, and obtaining a permit can take time. “Based on the calls we receive, these permits can take anywhere from 48 hours to several weeks to be approved,” Salazar said.

Desmond, from Sing Sing, was able to buy a six-inch fan. It’s barely enough to cool his face, let alone his cell, he said.

Conditions at Sing Sing appear even more dire than in other facilities. Administrators recently reported that roughly 100 corrections officers at the facility are calling out sick every day. “These people don’t come to work,” Desmond said.

That makes beating the heat a particularly tall order. Desmond would love to cool off with regular showers, but the facility has only been taking the men to shower for a few minutes three times a week, he said — and the water lately has come out hot.

While conditions this summer are especially oppressive, advocates have fielded complaints about extreme heat in New York prisons for years as temperatures have risen due to climate change. At Great Meadow Correctional Facility in 2021, incarcerated people told Scaife’s Correctional Association that it was so hot — and corrections officers ignored their complaints so often — that one man started a fire in an attempt to force staff to open windows. During oversight visits to Elmira and Coxsackie prisons the following summer, incarcerated people complained to the organization about extreme heat exacerbated by lack of ventilation. There was no cold water and not enough fans to go around, they said.

Air conditioning would resolve these issues, but it would require a massive investment. Many of New York’s prison buildings, some of which were built in the 1800s, would need new electrical infrastructure to support air conditioning units, Scaife said. And DOCCS is in the middle of other large capital projects, like a nearly billion-dollar effort to install system-wide security camera coverage, fast-tracked after a fatal beatdown by corrections officers in December.

“The scale of the issues right now, it’s just so great,” Scaife said. While heat exacerbates other problems, it falls low on the priority list for DOCCS administration and elected officials, she said. “Because it’s seasonal, they’ll just kind of move beyond it.”

With air conditioning unlikely to be installed anytime soon, Scaife’s organization has called for DOCCS to develop and publish detailed plans to ensure that incarcerated people are able to cope with extreme heat. The department didn’t take up the recommendation, but last year, Hochul signed into law a bill that requires DOCCS to establish more heat mitigation regulations. Among other factors, the rules are meant to require staff to facilitate access to industrial fans and extra shower time and ensure that facilities are fully stocked with personal fans.